Food Politics: Should Sugar Be Taxed Like Tobacco and Alcohol?

by The Health Sciences Academy — Get free science updates here.

Sugar Tax

Photo Credit: Pixabay

Have you heard the news?

Harvard researchers reported in an abstract, presented at an American Heart Association scientific conference, that they have linked 180,000 obesity-related deaths worldwide to sugary drinks.

Heart disease, cancer and diabetes for the first time in human history pose a greater health burden worldwide than infectious disease.

Should sugar then be taxed?

Health scientists contend that there has been a massive rise in diseases such as heart disease, cancer and diabetes since we began eating more sugar contained in processed food. And since excessive sugar consumption shows similar effects as alcohol and tobacco, it is arguable that sugar should be controlled and taxed just the same.

Earlier this year, the World Health Organisation announced that the recommended level of sugar in people’s diet should be reduced fiercely.

What does this mean?

With the current recommended figure of 10 per cent of total intake from “free sugars” – mainly refined and fruit sugars – this ought to be cut in half, to 5 per cent.

Dame Sally Davies, the Chief Medical Officer for England, highlighted the addictive nature of sugar and commissioned ongoing research. Because of the addictive quality, she believes that the public needs to have a “big education” on how “sugar packed” juices, fizzy drinks and processed foods truly are.

So if this is all true – that sugar is addictive and produces risk factors for disease – should it be under the control of government through regulations?

Something similar happened in Denmark. In 2011 Denmark imposed a fat tax on meat, dairy products, and cooking oil. This move was introduced to limit the country’s intake of fatty foods. Less than a year and a half later that tax was abolished. Besides creating burdens and uncertainty it was questionable whether it ever did work according to its intention, to improve public health.

Do we need a Sugar Police?

Unfortunately, sugar is like cheap alcohol – it’s available everywhere. Clearly it’s in those Crunchies, Kit Kats, and Smarties, but it’s also hidden in pies, canned beans, crisps, salami, and even gravy too! Added sugars make food more palatable and manufacturers have long since realised that this boosts sales.

Since 1990, consumption of sugar in Britain has increased by 31 per cent – now we eat 1.25 lbs (.57 kilos) per person a week! Is sugar intake then actually a form of addiction, especially given the point that many people cannot stop eating it once they start?

Paul van der Velpen, head of Amsterdam’s health service, described sugar as “the most dangerous drug of the times”, causing a rapid high followed by increased cravings.

Shockingly, researchers at the University of Bordeaux discovered that sugar has a bigger impact than hard drugs in the brain: their experiments showed that refined sugar could be 4 times more addictive than cocaine.

Sure, we don’t necessarily buy sugar like those 1 kg bags you see. It’s that “invisible sugar” and the inconspicuous ways the food industry sneaks it into things that sinks our ships and drives us deeper into addiction.

It is so bad, that we have dedicated a full module on food addiction in our Advanced Clinical Weight Loss Practitioner certification.

So back to the sugar tax.

Just what would the sugar tax do?

The measures around this tax would include limiting the availability of ultra-processed foods and sweetened soft drinks, and banning “junk food sports sponsorships”.

When you look at the sugar strewn industry and the way it has affected our obesity, heart disease and diabetes rates, it seems that in the end we’ll have to pay for it – either in health or taxes. So what is it going to be?

Robert H. Lustig, an American pediatric endocrinologist at the University of California San Francisco, believes it should be controlled like alcohol and tobacco.


Lustig’s specialty is childhood obesity and he reminds us of the struggle with the tobacco industry, where it was and what it’s come to. As he says:

We made it expensive, harder to buy, and harder to advertise. We kept it away from children. We made it taboo.

Can we really do this with sugar?

Especially when we’re talking about Big Food and Big Sugar. The food industry does not want to change. This is big money.

The obesity expert Philip James puts it this way: “The sugar industry has learnt the tricks of the tobacco industry. Confuse the public. Produce experts who disagree. Try to dilute the message.”


What do you think?

There is evidence that suggests taxing say soft drinks won’t curb obesity. Then there’s the other side who argue that regulation is the only way to constrain Big Food. Some doctors in the UK suggest sugar is a greater threat to public health than smoking.

So, what’s the real answer? Should sugar be taxed?

Let’s vote:

Let's vote: Should sugar be taxed?


A tax on sugary drinks was introduced in the UK in March 2016:

Sugar Tax The Health Sciences Academy v2

Leave a comment below, add your voice to the conversation!

The-Health-Sciences-Academy-Alejandra-Ruani-small1-right Alex Ruani, Doctoral Researcher, is the Chief Science Educator at The Health Sciences Academy, where her team of accomplished scientists and PhDs are training a new breed of over 100,000 highly-specialised nutrition professionals who are leveraging the latest personalisation strategies to help their clients. She is a Harvard-trained scientist and UCL Doctoral Researcher who is fanatical about equipping health professionals with the latest science-based tools so they can succeed in their practices – from identifying the unique nutrient needs to building highly personalised nutrition programs. Besides investigating and teaching the latest advances in health and nutrition biochemistry, Alex makes it easier to be smarter with her free email updates.

Did you enjoy this? Sign up to receive our FREE email updates!

See Also

Continuing Education Bundle

Exclusive Webinar

Empower Your Nutrition Practice: Clinic Toolkit Workshop and Insider Tips (plus Live Q&A)

Are you ready to empower your nutrition practice? Join us for an exclusive open-to-all workshop with our CEO, Maurice Castelijn, designed to help you unwrap the full potential of the Clinic Toolkit™ and streamline your client work:

  • Unlock the power of the Clinic Toolkit™ to give your practice a competitive edge whilst saving you time
  • Game-changing upgrades that will attract new prospects and WOW your nutrition clients
  • Walkthrough of the latest features – and how to make the most of them to boost client retention and practice growth
  • Insider tips from its developers and fellow Clinic Toolkit™ users, setting yourself apart as a highly skilled nutrition professional
  • How to run personalised client programs using the Clinic Toolkit™, increasing client success rates and satisfaction
  • Insights into the powerful tracking features of the Clinic Toolkit™, allowing you to monitor client progress

Whether you are an existing user or considering it, this interactive session will showcase how you can get the most of the Clinic Toolkit™ and the latest features, such as:

  • Preset, done-for-you client programs
  • Branding that your client will see
  • Specific settings that allow for more automation
  • The ability to connect the Clinic Toolkit™ with anything else

This is also a good opportunity to ask any questions and to let us know what you would like to see next. Ultimately, the Clinic Toolkit™ is created for you to improve client engagement and save you time - all using the forms from your training with The Health Sciences Academy.

Register Now

Free Academic Tour

© Copyright

Everything on this site is original content, created and owned by or through The Health Sciences Academy ® or licensed accordingly.
Training Nutritionists of the Future™
© Copyright The Health Sciences Academy. The content, graphs and charts on this page have been exclusively prepared for The Health Sciences Academy and its prospect students, existing students and graduates. None of the content on this page and website may be reproduced, copied or altered without our explicit permission. Criminal and legal penalties for copyright and other infringement apply. All Terms and Conditions apply.
The Health Sciences Academy® is the world’s largest 100% science-based, nutrition-focused online educational institution.
✔ helping health and wellness professionals grow successful client practices
✔ raising industry standards since 2012 through personalised nutrition science
© Copyright The Health Sciences Academy. The content, graphs and charts on this page have been exclusively prepared for The Health Sciences Academy and its prospect students, existing students and graduates. None of the content on this page and website may be reproduced, copied or altered without our explicit permission. Criminal and legal penalties for copyright and other infringement apply. All Terms and Conditions apply.


Free Courses



About Us

© 2022 The Health Sciences Academy ® All Rights Reserved.